Talk:GbLAN: Difference between revisions

From PS3 Developer wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Updated test results)
(foda porra)
(45 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 8: Line 8:
==FTP speed changes between firmwares==
==FTP speed changes between firmwares==


*Updated test results
CECH-2001B
Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock


LV2 Kernel mode : CEX
{| class="wikitable"
Cobra payload : Disabled
|-
Network : 1Gbps bridged between PS3/PC via LAN
! colspan="3" | Firmware !! colspan="2" | Av. Speed (MB/s) !! colspan="2" | FTP software !! colspan="2" | Network setup !! rowspan="2" | Other notes
FTP Client : Filezilla 3.14.0
|-
FTP Server : REBUG TOOLBOX 2.02.XX [openFTP]
! Name and version !! Cobra !! Plugins !! PS3 to PC !! PC to PS3 !! Client (PC) !! Server (PS3) !! PC NIC !! Wiring
|-
| Rebug 3.55.4 || {{No2|No}} || {{No2|No}} || 52 || 32 || Filezilla 3.14.0 || Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX || Gigabit ethernet || direct, CAT5e || CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
|-
| Rebug 4.21.2 || {{No2|No}} || {{No2|No}} || 52 || 32 || Filezilla 3.14.0 || Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX || Gigabit ethernet || direct, CAT5e || CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
|-
|Rebug 4.21.2 + '''4.30 CEX LV2'''|| {{No2|No}} || {{No2|No}} || 52 || 18.3 || Filezilla 3.14.0 || Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX || Gigabit ethernet || direct, CAT5e || Using 4.30 CEX LV2 causes the immediate speed drop on FTP
|-
| JoonBug 4.25.1 || {{No2|No}} || {{No2|No}} || 52 || 32 || Filezilla 3.14.0 || Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX || Gigabit ethernet || direct, CAT5e || CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
|-
| Rebug 4.30.2 || {{No2|No}} || {{No2|No}} || 52 || 18.5 || Filezilla 3.14.0 || Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX || Gigabit ethernet || direct, CAT5e || CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
|-
| Rebug 4.41.3 || {{No2|No}} || {{No2|No}} || 52 || 18.5 || Filezilla 3.14.0 || Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX || Gigabit ethernet || direct, CAT5e || CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
|-
| Rebug 4.46.1 || {{No2|No}} || {{No2|No}} || 52 || 18.5 || Filezilla 3.14.0 || Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX || Gigabit ethernet || direct, CAT5e || CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
|-
| Rebug 4.46.1 LITE || {{No2|No}} || {{No2|No}} || 34 || 21 || Filezilla 3.8.0 || IrisManager 2.93 || Gigabit PCI card || direct, 10 meters CAT5e || CECH-25xx with factory TOSHIBA [[MK3265GSX]] 320GB
|-
| Rebug 4.46.1 LITE || {{No2|No}} || {{No2|No}} || 41.5 || 19 || Filezilla 3.8.0 || Rebug toolbox || Gigabit PCI card || direct, 10 meters CAT5e || CECH-25xx with factory TOSHIBA [[MK3265GSX]] 320GB
|-
| Rogero 4.60 || {{No2|No}} || {{No2|No}} || 50 || 18 || Filezilla 3.14.0 || Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX || Gigabit ethernet || direct, CAT5e || CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
|-
| PS3ITA 4.65 DEX || {{No2|No}} || {{No2|No}} || 35 || 22 || FlashFxp 4.2.5 || PS3ITA Manager || Gigabit ethernet || direct, CAT5e || CECH-25xx with factory hdd 160GB
|-
| PS3ITA 4.65 DEX || {{No2|No}} || {{No2|No}} || 14 || 18 || ProDG 4.00 || Native || Gigabit ethernet || direct, CAT5e || CECH-25xx with factory hdd 160GB
|-
| Rebug 4.65.2 || {{No2|Disabled}} || {{No2|Disabled}} || 50 || 18.5 || Filezilla 3.14.0 || Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX || Gigabit ethernet || direct, CAT5e || CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
|-
| Rebug 4.70.1 || {{No2|Disabled}} || {{No2|Disabled}} || 50 || 18.5 || Filezilla 3.14.0 || Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX || Gigabit ethernet || direct, CAT5e || CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
|-
| Habib 4.70 v2 || {{Yes2|Enabled}} || {{No2|Disabled}} || 50 || 18.2 || Filezilla 3.14.0 || Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX || Gigabit ethernet || direct, CAT5e || CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
|-
| Habib CEX 4.70 || {{No2|Disabled}} || {{No2|Disabled}} || 40.46 || 20.19 || FlashFxp 4.4.4 || OpenPS3FTP 2.3 || Gigabit ethernet || Gigabit Switch, CAT6 || CECH-25xx with WD 1TB Internal HDD. Test File size: 3.41GB
|-
| Habib CEX 4.70 || {{No2|Disabled}} || {{No2|Disabled}} || 45 || 19 || Filezilla 3.14.0|| OpenPS3FTP 2.3 || Gigabit ethernet || Gigabit Switch, CAT6 || CECH-25xx with WD 1TB Internal HDD. Test File size: 3.41GB
|-
| Habib 4.75 v4 || {{Yes2|Enabled}} || {{No2|Disabled}} || 50 || 18.2 || Filezilla 3.14.0 || Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX || Gigabit ethernet || direct, CAT5e || CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
|-
| Rebug 4.75.3 || {{No2|Disabled}} || {{No2|Disabled}} || 50 || 18.5 || Filezilla 3.14.0 || Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX || Gigabit ethernet || direct, CAT5e || CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
|-
| Rebug 4.76.1 || {{No2|Disabled}} || {{No2|Disabled}} || 50 || 18.5 || Filezilla 3.14.0 || Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX || Gigabit ethernet || direct, CAT5e || CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
|-
| Rebug 4.76.1 Lite || {{No2|Disabled}} || {{No2|Disabled}} || 33.53 || 18.09 || FlashFxp 4.4.4 || OpenPS3FTP 4.0 || Gigabit ethernet || Gigabit Switch, CAT6 || CECH-25xx Test File size: 3.41GB
|-
| Rebug 4.76.1 Lite || {{No2|Disabled}} || {{No2|Disabled}} || 34.30 || 20.67 || FlashFxp 4.4.4 || OpenPS3FTP 4.1 || Gigabit ethernet || Gigabit Switch, CAT6 || CECH-25xx Test File size: 3.41GB
|-
| Rebug 4.76.1 Lite || {{No2|Disabled}} || {{No2|Disabled}} || 29.50 || 19.75 || FlashFxp 4.4.4 || webMAN 1.47n || Gigabit ethernet || Gigabit Switch, CAT6 || CECH-25xx Test File size: 3.41GB
|-
| Rebug 4.76.1 Lite || {{No2|Disabled}} || {{No2|Disabled}} || 34.02 || 20.13 || FlashFxp 4.4.4 || OpenPS3FTP 4.2 || Gigabit ethernet || Gigabit Switch, CAT6 || CECH-25xx Test File size: 3.41GB
|}


UL = from PS3 to PC
*Notes
DL = from PC to PS3
**The speeds in the table are the average speeds, not the peaks, to stabilize speeds is needed to transfer a single file of size 2GB or bigger and take note of the speed average after the transfer is completed
Speed rate : Mb/s
**The FTP code included inside rebug toolbox is based on OpenPS3FTP.
**More results have been updated and also existing results got updated as well, [REBUG 4.70.1/4.75.3]
**FTP Speed seems to be the same since 4.30 update until 4.76
**Iris Manager v2.93 (last official version by estwald)... and probably all its forks (ps3ita manager, etc...) has a problem of slow speeds when transfering files PS3 to PC
'''********* Using 4.30 LV2 while on 4.21.2 REX causes the immediate speed drop on ftp.. the answer seems to be found on LV2 kernel ********'''
*Discussion threads in forums:
**http://www.psx-place.com/forum/general-ps3-discussion/discussion-research-ftp-speed-changes-firmwares-3040.html


REBUG FW  |  UL/DL
<br />
        3.55.4  |  52/32
        4.21.2  |  52/32
        4.30.2  |  52/18.5
        4.41.3  |  52/18.5
        4.46.1  |  52/18.5
        4.70.1  |  32/18.5
        4.75.3  |  32/18.5


==FTP speed changes between firmwares==
[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_FTP_client_software Notable FTP clients:]
<+Joonie> confirmed
* [https://filezilla-project.org/ Filezilla] http://sourceforge.net/projects/filezilla/files/FileZilla_Client/ https://filezilla-project.org/versions.php
<+Joonie> 3.55 is a lot faster than 4.xx [ftp]
* [https://winscp.net/ WinSCP]
<+Joonie> 30 -> 50 , 18 -> 32
* [http://gftp.seul.org/ gFTP]
<+Joonie> damn
* [https://cyberduck.io/ Cyberduck]
<+Joonie> 4.21 is as fast as 3.55
* [https://www.flashfxp.com/ FlashFxp]
<+Joonie> going to try 4.46 too
 
<+Joonie> I get 32/52 while on 3.55/4.21
Servers
<+Joonie> did more test on ftp
* https://github.com/jjolano/openps3ftp https://github.com/jjolano/openps3ftp/releases
<+Joonie> rebug 4.46.1 official speed drop is shown comparing to 4.21.2
<+Joonie> from PS3 to PC is still as fast as 3.55 [52mb/s]
<+Joonie> from PC to PS3 is 18mb/s [same as 4.76.1]
<+Joonie> so
<+Joonie> 4.46.1 is slower than 4.21.2 and 3.55.4
<+Joonie> 4.21.2 is as fast as 3.55.4
<+Joonie> 4.46.1 is still a little bit better than 4.75.3 or 4.70.1
<+Joonie> tests are all done via toolbox 2.02.08[openFTP] without cobra
<+Joonie> PC/PS3 are bridged via LAN 1Gbps
*the talk has been edited to short it, are just notes to not forget the results of the speed tests, is needed further research to know what is happening, in wich firmware happened, and the exact speed reductions

Revision as of 12:40, 4 March 2017

Requests/missing:

  • Datasheets Marvell 88E6108-LAR1
  • Datasheets Marvell Alaska 88E111R 88E1118R-NNC2
  • If Jumbo frames is limited by hardware or hypervisor

FTP speed changes between firmwares

Firmware Av. Speed (MB/s) FTP software Network setup Other notes
Name and version Cobra Plugins PS3 to PC PC to PS3 Client (PC) Server (PS3) PC NIC Wiring
Rebug 3.55.4 No No 52 32 Filezilla 3.14.0 Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX Gigabit ethernet direct, CAT5e CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
Rebug 4.21.2 No No 52 32 Filezilla 3.14.0 Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX Gigabit ethernet direct, CAT5e CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
Rebug 4.21.2 + 4.30 CEX LV2 No No 52 18.3 Filezilla 3.14.0 Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX Gigabit ethernet direct, CAT5e Using 4.30 CEX LV2 causes the immediate speed drop on FTP
JoonBug 4.25.1 No No 52 32 Filezilla 3.14.0 Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX Gigabit ethernet direct, CAT5e CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
Rebug 4.30.2 No No 52 18.5 Filezilla 3.14.0 Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX Gigabit ethernet direct, CAT5e CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
Rebug 4.41.3 No No 52 18.5 Filezilla 3.14.0 Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX Gigabit ethernet direct, CAT5e CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
Rebug 4.46.1 No No 52 18.5 Filezilla 3.14.0 Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX Gigabit ethernet direct, CAT5e CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
Rebug 4.46.1 LITE No No 34 21 Filezilla 3.8.0 IrisManager 2.93 Gigabit PCI card direct, 10 meters CAT5e CECH-25xx with factory TOSHIBA MK3265GSX 320GB
Rebug 4.46.1 LITE No No 41.5 19 Filezilla 3.8.0 Rebug toolbox Gigabit PCI card direct, 10 meters CAT5e CECH-25xx with factory TOSHIBA MK3265GSX 320GB
Rogero 4.60 No No 50 18 Filezilla 3.14.0 Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX Gigabit ethernet direct, CAT5e CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
PS3ITA 4.65 DEX No No 35 22 FlashFxp 4.2.5 PS3ITA Manager Gigabit ethernet direct, CAT5e CECH-25xx with factory hdd 160GB
PS3ITA 4.65 DEX No No 14 18 ProDG 4.00 Native Gigabit ethernet direct, CAT5e CECH-25xx with factory hdd 160GB
Rebug 4.65.2 Disabled Disabled 50 18.5 Filezilla 3.14.0 Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX Gigabit ethernet direct, CAT5e CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
Rebug 4.70.1 Disabled Disabled 50 18.5 Filezilla 3.14.0 Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX Gigabit ethernet direct, CAT5e CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
Habib 4.70 v2 Enabled Disabled 50 18.2 Filezilla 3.14.0 Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX Gigabit ethernet direct, CAT5e CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
Habib CEX 4.70 Disabled Disabled 40.46 20.19 FlashFxp 4.4.4 OpenPS3FTP 2.3 Gigabit ethernet Gigabit Switch, CAT6 CECH-25xx with WD 1TB Internal HDD. Test File size: 3.41GB
Habib CEX 4.70 Disabled Disabled 45 19 Filezilla 3.14.0 OpenPS3FTP 2.3 Gigabit ethernet Gigabit Switch, CAT6 CECH-25xx with WD 1TB Internal HDD. Test File size: 3.41GB
Habib 4.75 v4 Enabled Disabled 50 18.2 Filezilla 3.14.0 Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX Gigabit ethernet direct, CAT5e CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
Rebug 4.75.3 Disabled Disabled 50 18.5 Filezilla 3.14.0 Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX Gigabit ethernet direct, CAT5e CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
Rebug 4.76.1 Disabled Disabled 50 18.5 Filezilla 3.14.0 Rebug toolbox 2.02.XX Gigabit ethernet direct, CAT5e CECH-20xx with Seagate 500GB 3.5" via E-SATA dock. LV2 Kernel mode: CEX
Rebug 4.76.1 Lite Disabled Disabled 33.53 18.09 FlashFxp 4.4.4 OpenPS3FTP 4.0 Gigabit ethernet Gigabit Switch, CAT6 CECH-25xx Test File size: 3.41GB
Rebug 4.76.1 Lite Disabled Disabled 34.30 20.67 FlashFxp 4.4.4 OpenPS3FTP 4.1 Gigabit ethernet Gigabit Switch, CAT6 CECH-25xx Test File size: 3.41GB
Rebug 4.76.1 Lite Disabled Disabled 29.50 19.75 FlashFxp 4.4.4 webMAN 1.47n Gigabit ethernet Gigabit Switch, CAT6 CECH-25xx Test File size: 3.41GB
Rebug 4.76.1 Lite Disabled Disabled 34.02 20.13 FlashFxp 4.4.4 OpenPS3FTP 4.2 Gigabit ethernet Gigabit Switch, CAT6 CECH-25xx Test File size: 3.41GB
  • Notes
    • The speeds in the table are the average speeds, not the peaks, to stabilize speeds is needed to transfer a single file of size 2GB or bigger and take note of the speed average after the transfer is completed
    • The FTP code included inside rebug toolbox is based on OpenPS3FTP.
    • More results have been updated and also existing results got updated as well, [REBUG 4.70.1/4.75.3]
    • FTP Speed seems to be the same since 4.30 update until 4.76
    • Iris Manager v2.93 (last official version by estwald)... and probably all its forks (ps3ita manager, etc...) has a problem of slow speeds when transfering files PS3 to PC

********* Using 4.30 LV2 while on 4.21.2 REX causes the immediate speed drop on ftp.. the answer seems to be found on LV2 kernel ********


Notable FTP clients:

Servers

Retrieved from "http://www.psdevwiki.com/ps3/index.php?title=Talk:GbLAN&oldid=43616"